The Emerald Isle has always been known for its wit, humor, and love of a good argument. So, let’s dive into a topic that’s been sweeping the nation, and indeed the world, with a bit of Irish flair. Today, we’re going to tackle the rather sticky issue of trans-identifying male violence. Now, before we begin, let me don my tin helmet and acknowledge that discussing this topic can be a bit of a minefield. But, as the great Irish philosopher, Oscar Wilde, once said, “To love oneself is the beginning of a lifelong romance.” And, I’d add, to discuss the uncomfortable truths is the beginning of a lifelong pursuit of wisdom.
As we delve into the world of statistics and data, it’s essential to remember that numbers don’t lie, but they can be mighty uncomfortable. According to a report from the UK-based group Fair Play For Women, which obtained its information through Freedom of Information requests, a staggering 60% of male-born transgender inmates in England and Wales were convicted of violent crimes, and 50% were convicted of sexual offenses, including rape. Now, to put that into perspective, among the general male prison population, only 18% are serving time for sexual offenses. That means trans-identifying males are nearly three times more likely to be imprisoned for sex crimes than even other men.
But, me boyos, it gets even more alarming. These figures are drawn from the Ministry of Justice’s own data, and they’re not just some cherry-picked anecdotes. In one infamous case, a biological male named Karen White, who self-identified as a trans woman, was placed in a UK women’s prison despite having been convicted of raping multiple women. Within days of arrival, he assaulted two more female inmates. This wasn’t a tragic oversight; it was an ideological policy in action.
Now, I know what you’re thinking: “What’s behind this madness?” Well, it’s quite simple, really. Gender self-identification policies have taken precedence over biological reality. That means anyone who claims to be a woman, regardless of medical transition, criminal record, or sex crime history, can gain access to women’s facilities and legal protections. It’s a bit like giving a fox the keys to the henhouse, if you know what I mean.
The trans activist movement insists that these are isolated incidents, but with violent crime rates disproportionately higher among trans-identifying males, the real question is: how many women have to suffer before we reconsider our approach? It’s a bit like the old Irish saying goes: “If you’re not living on the edge, you’re taking up too much space.” And, in this case, the edge is the safety and dignity of women.
But, as we all know, bringing these facts to light can be a bit of a cultural heresy. Writers like Abigail Shrier, feminist icons like J.K. Rowling, and even formerly progressive LGBTQ+ voices have all faced boycotts, censorship, and even death threats for daring to question the dogma. It’s a bit like trying to silence a Dublin pub on a Friday night – it’s just not going to happen.
And then, of course, there’s the rise of Transtifa, a loosely affiliated but growing movement of radical trans activists who adopt Antifa tactics: black bloc, masked intimidation, and violent protest. According to reports, Transtifa activists have shown up at women’s rights rallies, physically attacking speakers, throwing projectiles, and even carrying weapons – all under the justification of fighting “transphobia.” It’s a bit like the old IRA slogan: “Tiocfaidh ár lá” or “Our day will come.” But, in this case, it’s more like “Our day will come, and we’ll smash it to pieces.”
Now, I’m not saying that all trans people are violent, but the silence on this issue is deafening. The refusal to address the significant and measurable risk posed by a subset of trans-identifying males does not help them; it undermines public trust and creates backlash. It’s a bit like the old Irish proverb: “A shut mouth catches no f
